© 2015 All materials on this site are the property of the site owners and may not be removed or used without written permission.
Changing the actions, aptitudes and attitudes of dogs and their people
Can We Have The Training Commands?
We are thinking about adopting Max from the xxxxxx Humane Society.
We were told that he received training at your facility. Did Max have any issues we need to be aware of. We have
grandchildren ages 1,2 and 3. Would he be comfortable with them? (One is a little leary of dogs.)
We are also concerned with maintaining his training. Could you let us know what commands he knows?
Any information would be greatly appreciated.
Please feel free to explore our website to get a sense of our philosophy regarding dog training.
In a nutshell, our professional opinion is that dogs are a reflection of the relationship they have with their people.
This is similar to how a child can be an angel with Grandma Jones, but is a hellion with Grandma Smith. Or, how kids
are well behaved when with one teacher, but are completely out of control with a different teacher (or school bus
driver, or coach, or aunt or parent). It's the same kid - different relationship.
If a child has been trained to make his bed in the morning, he will make his bed in the morning when he is with his
mother. She does not even have to remind the child. The bed is made, and made well, before he comes down stairs
for breakfast. But, when his father is the one in charge, the kid often doesn't make his bed. Does that suggest the
child doesn't know how to make a bed? Or, does it suggest that the father doesn't have the same standards for the
child's behavior? We would argue that dogs and kids fall into the latter category (you can teach them to perform at a
very high standard, but if they don't believe in your authority, they won't always do what they know how to do).
For that reason, “training comands” do not transfer the way that you hope it might. On the same day, within the
same hour (or even same 30 minutes), a dog can behave exceedingly well when with one person and as soon as the
leash goes into the hands of another person, the dog will act out; sometimes very badly. We have hundreds of hours
of video evidence of that phenomenon. You are not acquiring a refrigerator that has been calibrated to stay at a
specific temperature. A dog reads the person "in charge" and decides whether he can trust that person's authority.
Our concept of "dog training" requires as much "people training" to make certain the dog can trust the owner's
authority, as it does educating the dog.
There is no way for us to assess Max's behavior at this time. An assessment would require not only seeing him, but
meeting who is handling/ owning / controlling him. We video recorded Max's training when he was with us. We
spend 5-6 hours (perhaps more) with his owners at their Board/Train pick-up appointment. A few weeks later, based
on an email correspondence, it seemed that Max's owners were not following through with the recommendations for
proper management and training that we suggested. That could have had a negative influence on him, since he
learned that the standards we set with him do not need to be followed. But, we can always get a dog back to the
level of behavior he was when he left here, after training. It just may take longer for the dog to believe in our
authority, since he learned it doesn't apply all the time. Teaching animals (from frogs to humans) is a complicated
art, not a clear-cut, black & white science.
My husband, Robert, did discuss these concepts with the representative from the xxxxxxx Humane Society. We are
surprised that she may have suggested you can just get a "download" of the training commands that Max learned
when he was here and you'd be able to communicate with him at the level he was when he left here after
Board/Train. It just doesn't work like that, at least not in our professional experience.
I am sorry if my answer isn't what you were hoping.
© 2010 Tammie Rogers - all rights reserved.
For permission to reprint email
B/T Enrollment Form
Classes: One Day Workshop
Border Collie Puppies
METHODS & PHILOSOPHY
What Makes A Happy Dog?
When Board/Train is the better option
Can you train my 8 week old puppy?
Dealing with a Thunder phobic dog
Training a fearful dog
Selecting a breed as a Service Dog
How To Select A Dog Trainer
I am my dog's leader
Why do dogs need leadership?
Choosing the right breed for your lifestyle
Personality vs. Behavior
How to research a breeder
Crate training issues
Discussing breed standards
Response to a critique of our methods
How to acquire a puppy
How Can I Become a Breeder?
Dogs Must Die
Q & A
Need Help! with my rescue puppy
Transferring Training Commands
Did I buy a puppy that is too young?
Help! My puppy is biting!
What breed should I get?
Teaching older dog to accept puppy
How do I correct my pitbull?
How do we evidence training?
Does my dog need obedience or a hobby?
Will my dog revert after professional training
Rescue Syndrome or housebreaking problem?
Will my dog still run away?
An issue with kids and dogs
Will training break my dogs spirit?